From Fenner Tanswell
The news of Peter’s death is extremely sad, and he will be greatly missed. I knew Peter as a teacher, mentor, and colleague, and he undertook all of these roles with kindness, joy, and generosity.
I first met Peter as an undergraduate, where he taught us logic, philosophy of science, and philosophy of mathematics. Peter kindly allowed me to join an Mlitt class on the philosophy of maths during my third year and then, during the summer, he helped me to secure a research internship to work with him, comparing Frege and Dedekind’s treatment of the natural numbers. This was an absolute blast (as you would expect from the topic). Despite how busy he was in the Principal’s Office, he would meet with me every week in his office in Edgecliffe overlooking the sea, sit by the window with a cigarette in his hand (he told me not to tell anyone about this rule violation; sorry Peter!), and talk about infinities, successor functions, and mathematical reality.
During his seminars, Peter would always come in, ask what the topic was, pause for a moment, and then tell us all about detailed philosophical and mathematical ideas, entirely off the cuff without notes or slides. We loved his style and drama for presenting these ideas too; especially the phrase “the snake had already entered Eden” to describe Russell’s paradox shattering Frege’s foundational project. His knowledge and intellectual vigour were clear for all to see.
The St Andrews Philsoc once held a debate for St George’s day about who was the greatest English philosopher of all time, a distinction that we awarded to Peter after Jael, the society president, made the case for him all while doing a hilarious and eerily accurate impression. I stand by our decision.
Peter was not just beloved by philosophers, but by all who met him. Friends regularly told me about interesting encounters and discussions they had had with him at assorted university events. A stand-out anecdote from a friend, who worked with Peter via the student union, involved her taking a kids’ size carton of juice left from a previous meeting’s catering, which he found hilarious. Peter then made sure there was a carton of juice for her at every meeting she attended for the whole year, illustrating both his thoughtful and mischievous sides.
Peter’s guidance and mentoring has had a huge impact on my life. More than a decade later, I am still working in philosophy of mathematics, and interested in many of the same topics that Peter set me on the path towards. I am extremely grateful for all he did for me, and know that St Andrews will feel much emptier without him.